MOT performance
Porsche Macan vs BMW X4: MOT pass rates compared
In 2023–2024, 91.2% of 56,741 Porsche Macan MOT tests and 85.1% of 33,200 BMW X4 tests passed first time — 6.2 points in favour of the Porsche Macan. Once age, mileage and fuel are allowed for, the Porsche Macan fails less often than the BMW X4: 0.48× against 0.78× the national rate for comparable cars.
56,741 Porsche Macan and 33,200 BMW X4 MOT tests, 2023–2024
Check a specific car's MOT history and running costsAt a glance
| Figure | Value | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Porsche Macan: first-time pass rate | 91.2% | ±0.2 pts (95%), n = 56,741 |
| BMW X4: first-time pass rate | 85.1% | ±0.4 pts (95%), n = 33,200 |
| Porsche Macan: failures vs similar cars | -52% | same age, mileage and fuel = 1.00 |
| BMW X4: failures vs similar cars | -22% | same age, mileage and fuel = 1.00 |
| Porsche Macan: dangerous defect | 2.6% | n = 56,741 |
| BMW X4: dangerous defect | 5.2% | n = 33,200 |
| Average age at test | 5.3 vs 5.3 years | Porsche Macan vs BMW X4 |
Why the raw pass rates can mislead
The BMW X4 was tested at an older average age (5.3 years against 5.3), and older cars fail more often whatever they are. That is why the table above also shows failures against cars of the same age, mileage and fuel: it compares the models, not their fleets.
Failure areas side by side
Share of MOT tests that failed on each area, and in brackets how that compares with cars of the same age, mileage and fuel (1.00 = national average). The clearest difference is body, chassis and structure, where the Porsche Macan fails 6.6 times as often on an adjusted basis.
| Area | Porsche Macan | BMW X4 |
|---|---|---|
| Brakes | 1.0% (-73%) | 1.9% (-51%) |
| Steering | 0.2% (-77%) | 0.2% (-66%) |
| Suspension | 0.5% (-83%) | 2.4% (-31%) |
| Tyres | 3.9% (-31%) | 6.1% (+2%) |
| Road wheels | 0.1% (-40%) | 0.4% (+47%) |
| Lights, reflectors and electrical | 1.8% (-61%) | 2.6% (-49%) |
| Body, chassis and structure | 1.0% (+2%) | 0.2% (-84%) |
| Driver's view of the road | 0.8% (-76%) | 3.2% (-5%) |
| Noise, emissions and leaks | 0.4% (-71%) | 0.9% (-45%) |
| Seat belts and airbags | 0.2% (-59%) | 0.3% (-44%) |
| Registration plates and VIN | 0.4% (+107%) | 0.6% (+102%) |
Pass rate at the same age
Comparing cars of the same age removes most of the fleet-age effect from the raw rates.
| Age at test | Porsche Macan | BMW X4 |
|---|---|---|
| 3-4 years | 93.8% (n = 15,550) | 89.0% (n = 10,833) |
| 5-6 years | 92.1% (n = 17,907) | 85.1% (n = 9,215) |
| 7-8 years | 88.2% (n = 14,692) | 79.9% (n = 8,657) |
| 9-10 years | 83.7% (n = 3,217) | 81.5% (n = 1,839) |
Most common failure item
- Porsche Macan · condition: has a cut in excess of the requirements deep enough to reach the ply or cords (1.37% of tests)
- BMW X4 · tread depth: tread depth below requirements of 1.6mm (2.05% of tests)
MOT results reflect how cars are maintained as well as how they are built, so a gap between two models is a difference in test performance, not proof that one is more reliable. For one car, its own MOT history says more than any average.
Check a specific car
Enter a UK registration to see that car's own MOT history and what it is likely to cost to own. Your first check is free and shows the vehicle summary and its headline ownership cost. The category-by-category breakdown is part of a paid check.
UK number plate or 17-character VIN
About this data. These are MOT test results, not a measure of mechanical reliability: a car's MOT outcome reflects its condition on the day, which depends on how it has been maintained and driven as well as how it was built. Figures cover class 4 vehicles (cars and light vans), normal tests only (retests excluded), outcomes pass, fail and pass after rectification at the station; vehicles at least 2.5 years old at test. Tests from 2023-01-01 to 2024-12-30. “Compared with similar cars” means compared with the national rate for cars of the same age, mileage band and fuel. Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0. Makes and models are matched to 73 Auto's vehicle catalogue; tests that can't be matched are left out rather than guessed. See how the MOT figures are produced.